Best Oven Proof Skillets

The Best Oven-Proof Skillets for Safety and Convenience

Disclaimer: As an Amazon affiliate, I may earn a small commission from select products purchased on this page. All opinions are my own.

Sharing is caring!

Oven Proof skillets and cookware offer many conveniences, by letting you start out cooking on the stove top and then finishing it in the oven, all without having to switch pots and pans.

There are many factors that go into selecting a truly oven proof skillet. In this post. I’ll list those criteria before showing you my 5 favorite oven proof skillets currently on the market.

Checklist for Selecting an Oven Proof Skillet

If you’re planning to go from stove to oven, there are several things that you need to be aware of when buying oven-safe cookware.

  • Cookware Material – The best oven proof materials are cast iron, stainless steel, copper, aluminum, ceramic, or a combination of these materials.
  • Coating – The nonstick coating of the cookware can limit its heat-resistance. Very high temperatures can affect the lifespan of ceramic and enamel coatings so they should be limited to temperatures between 450 to 500°F. Seasoned cast iron cookware is slightly more tolerant to high heat, being safe up to 500°F. As for Teflon or PTFE coating, it should never be used above 500°F since it will start to emit toxic gases.
  • Handle Material – Companies often equip their products with handles that don’t get hot easily for safety. However, these types of handles often bring down the oven temperature rating. For example, stainless steel and cast iron handles are safe up to 500°F. But, they get hot so manufacturers use silicone insulated handles which are safe up to 350°F to 482°F. Bakelite handles are even less heat-resistant, being rated only up to 350°F.
  • Detachable Handle – To solve the problem posed by the handle material, some companies manufacture oven-safe cookware with detachable handles to take them out of the equation when in the oven.
  • Oven Proof Lids– Lids with plastic knobs can melt at high temperatures. One remedy to use with existing skillets is to replace the plastic knobs with stainless ones to make them oven-safe.

Best Oven Proof Skillets Reviewed

Taking into account all of the above, here are my choice for the 5 best oven proof skillets you can buy right now.

COOKER KING Nonstick Ceramic Frying Pans

COOKER KING Ceramic Nonstick Frying Pans, Stain Resistant, Dishwasher/Oven Safe, Toxin-Free,...
  • HEALTHY FRYING PANS: No PFOA, PFAS and Cadmium, ensuring no toxin fume at any temperature. Safe cooking to 480°F
  • DURABLE CERAMIC NONSTICK: Expert interior coating is easy to release food and clean up, never blisters, chips off or tarnishes
  • EXTREME CONVENIENCE: Dishwasher safe without damaging the ceramic coating; Oven safe to 480°F; Compatible with all stovetops except induction

Oven-Safe Temperature: Up to 480°F

Handle Material: Stainless steel

Coating: Ceramic

Nonstick: Yes

Cooktop Compatibility: All stovetops except induction

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Average Weight: 5.5 lbs for the three pieces

Pieces: 8″, 10″, 12″ frying pans

What We Liked About this Frying Pan

The Cooker King is our choice for oven-proof ceramic cookware because of its combination of affordability, flexibility, and performance. Not only is it suitable for most types of cooktops, we love that it has a high oven-safe temperature of 480°F, good enough to handle most recipes. A buyer said that she likes that this cookware allows her to start the dish on the stove and finish cooking it in the oven.

Another feature that makes this a great product is its dual-riveted stainless steel handle which stays cool when used on a cooktop. We also find the addition of the small hole in the handles a nice touch. Instead of nesting the pans which can scratch their ceramic interior, we can hang them when they’re not in use.

What We Didn’t Like So Much

The handles get hot if you use them in the oven. But, this is very common and easily solved by using mitts. We also don’t like that the handles feel sharp to the hands.

Lodge 10.25” Cast Iron Skillet

Sale
Lodge Cast Iron Skillet, Pre-Seasoned and Ready for Stove Top or Oven Use, 10.25", Black
  • 10.25 Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet. An improvement on the original: the Lodge Cast Iron Skillet, featuring an assist handle. This will be your go-to pan for generations to come. Handle length is...
  • SEASONED COOKWARE. A good seasoning makes all the difference. Lodge seasons its cookware with 100% vegetable oil; no synthetic coatings or chemicals. The more you use your iron, the better the...
  • MADE IN THE USA. Lodge has been making cast iron cookware in South Pittsburg, Tennessee (pop. 3,300) since 1896. With over 120 years of experience, their cast iron is known for its high quality...

Oven-Safe Temperature: Up to 500°F

Handle Material: Cast iron

Coating: Seasoning

Nonstick: Yes

Cooktop Compatibility: All types of heat source except microwave oven

Dishwasher-Safe: Hand washing recommended

Average Weight: 5.67 lbs

Dimensions: 16.12 x 10.68 x 2 in

Pieces: 10.25” skillet (available in other sizes)

What We Liked About this Frying Pan

No list of oven-proof cookware is complete without Amazon’s best-selling cast iron skillet, the Lodge. It’s one of the most versatile pieces we’ve tested, being compatible with all heat sources including a campfire and, of course, the oven. This cast iron skillet can handle temperatures more than any kitchen can ever produce. The 500°F rating is mainly for the seasoning which can disintegrate at very high temperatures.

According to one review, she uses the Lodge so much for cooking and baking that she just leaves it on her counter after washing. And, speaking of washing, we love that once the Lodge is properly seasoned, it’s nonstick and very easy to clean. Even better, the Lodge is budget-priced and can last so long you can make it your family heirloom.

What We Didn’t Like So Much

Just like all cast iron skillets, the Lodge is heavy and might not be suitable for you if you have trouble lifting heavy things. Also, since the handle is cast iron, you’ll have to be careful not to burn your hands.

Watch the video below for a quick demonstration of the Lodge:

Bruntmor 2-in-1 Enameled Cast Iron Double Dutch Oven & Skillet

2 in 1 Enameled Cast Iron Double Dutch Oven & Skillet Lid, 5-Quart, Fire Red - Induction, Electric,...
  • 5-quart pre-seasoned heavy duty cast iron dutch oven and casserole with a lid that doubles down as a skillet
  • Sturdy, integrated side handles on base and lid for secure transport and handling
  • Oven safe, hand wash recommended, unparalleled in heat retention and even heating

Oven-Safe Temperature: Up to 500°F

Handle Material: Enameled cast iron 

Coating: Enamel

Nonstick: Low-stick

Cooktop Compatibility: Gas, electric, ceramic glass top, and induction

Dishwasher-Safe: Hand washing recommended

Average Weight: 13 lbs

Dimensions: 5.98 x 5.98 x 4.02 in

Pieces: 5-qt Dutch oven with lid that doubles as skillet

Warranty: 1-year limited warranty

What We Liked About this Frying Pan

Bruntmor takes the regular enameled cast iron skillet to a whole new level by making it double as a lid for their Dutch oven. This means that you can cook more types of dishes, be it on the stove or in the oven. Since its side handles are also enameled cast iron, you can safely use this in the oven up to 500°F.

One buyer said that she likes that the food stays warm for a long time after she takes it out from the oven. We couldn’t agree more, and, to add to that, the Bruntmor heats up evenly. We also love that this vibrant piece can be used to serve the food. This means less kitchenware to wash, saving you time and energy.

What We Didn’t Like So Much

At 13 pounds once assembled, the Bruntmor is very heavy. This means that if you have a condition that makes it hard for you to lift heavy things, this isn’t the cookware for you. Plus, this tandem isn’t completely nonstick, so you’ll still need to use a bit of oil and proper temperature control to prevent food from sticking.

ICON Carbon Steel Skillet

Sale
ICON Carbon Steel Skillet (10-inch) - Pre-Seasoned - All-Natural Surface - Dishwasher Safe - Oven...
  • INCLUDES: 1oz bottle of Sunflower Oil (recommended oil) and Instructions for Additional Seasoning
  • 25-Year Consumer Warranty, 5-Year Commercial Warranty
  • 98% iron core, 30% lighter than traditional cast iron

Oven-Safe Temperature: Up to 800°F

Handle Material: Cast stainless steel

Coating: Seasoning

Nonstick: Yes

Cooktop Compatibility: All stovetops

Dishwasher-Safe: Hand washing recommended

Average Weight: 4.6 lbs

Dimensions: 3.5 x 18.5 x 11 in

Pieces: 10” skillet (available in 8”, 12”, and 14”)

Warranty: 25-year consumer warranty, 5-year commercial warranty

What We Liked About this Frying Pan

For people who can’t lift heavy cookware like the Lodge and Bruntmor, we highly recommend the ICON Carbon Steel Skillet as your go-to oven-proof cookware. It is only 4.6 pounds and is very similar to Lodge in terms of oven-safety. You can use it at extremely high temperatures of up to 800°F, but the seasoning will get burned off. In that case, you can just re-season the pan. Still, most recipes only require 500°F at maximum.

Other things we love about the Icon include its durability, nonstick properties once properly seasoned, and ability to heat up fast. As one user had commented, it’s a little high maintenance in that it needs to be seasoned every now and then, but it’s worth it. We’re also impressed by the 25-year consumer warranty which would make any buyer feel secure about the product they’re buying.

What We Didn’t Like So Much

Just like most stainless steel handles, the Icon’s handle gets hot when used in the oven. You have to be careful about sudden temperature changes as well since it can warp this skillet. Finally, the Icon is the most expensive product on our list, but we don’t mind paying a little extra for a product of this caliber.

Almond 10” Aluminum Skillet

Sale
Zelancio Enameled 10-Inch Cast Iron Skillet, Oven Safe Smooth Surface Frying Pan. Perfect for Steak,...
  • SKILLET: Perfect for cooking your favorite foods including steak, eggs, chicken, vegetables, and so much more!
  • VERSATILE: Our ovenproof skillet can go straight from stove to oven to table. Perfect to braise, sauté, simmer, bake, marinate, or slow simmer.
  • SUPERIOR DESIGN: Our coated cast iron skillet features an ergonomic handle, pour spouts, and superior heat distribution and retention to evenly tenderize meats, poultry, and vegetables.

Oven-Safe Temperature: Up to 450°F

Handle Material: Stainless steel

Coating: Teflon

Nonstick: Yes

Cooktop Compatibility: Gas, glass, electric, and induction cooktops

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Average Weight: 4 lbs

Dimensions: 17.2 x 10.91 x 3.9 in

Pieces: 10” skillet with glass lid

Warranty: 1-year warranty

What We Liked About this Frying Pan

When it comes to Teflon-coated oven-safe cookware, the Almond Aluminum Skillet is our top pick. Though it has the lowest maximum oven-safe temperature out of all the products on our list, 450°F is still high enough to handle most of your baking needs. Plus, unlike the Cooker King, the Almond comes with a vented glass lid that’s rated up to 500°F. One satisfied buyer that she was able to make chicken parmesan from the stove to the oven with great success.

Of course, since the coating is Teflon, nothing sticks and it’s very easy to clean. As long as you don’t exceed the temperature indicated on the manual, it’s very safe to use. We also like the handle of the Almond better than the Cooker King. It stays cool and is designed to be easy to grip.

What We Didn’t Like So Much

Some people dislike that there’s a slight dome in the center of the pan. This means that the liquids stay at the edge when you’re cooking. For us, however, this can be a good thing since the food won’t be as oily.

You can watch the Almond in action here:

Cooktop to Oven Recipes

To help you get started with your oven-proof skillet, here are some of our favorite recipes that start off on the cooktop and finish cooking in the oven.

Protecting Skillet Handles Past Their Oven-Safe Temperature

If you have a piece of cookware that a low oven-safe temperature because of its handle, Cook’s Illustrated has an easy workaround.

  • Wrap the handle in two layers of wet paper towels.
  • Cover the paper towels with two layers of foil.

Because of the water in the paper towels, the handle won’t get hotter than 212°F which is the boiling point of water. According to the tests they’ve done, this method can keep the handle below 350°F for 30 minutes in a 450°F oven and more than an hour in a 425°F oven.

Remember, even if the layers of paper towel and foil can keep the handle at a lower temperature, it will still be too hot to touch. Make sure to use mitts when taking out the cookware from the oven.

The Takeaway

An oven-proof skillet is your best friend if you want to cook dishes that go straight from the stovetop to the oven. Here are a few key points:

  • Stove-to-oven cooking is completely safe with the right oven-proof cookware.
  • An oven-proof skillet can reduce your cleanup time and save you energy.
  • There are different types of oven-proof skillets to choose from, depending on your needs.
  • You can save kitchen space by buying cookware that is oven-compatible too.

If you like the practicality that an oven-proof skillet can add to your kitchen, just pick from our 5 favorite oven-safe cookware brands.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*